I am kind of surprised that “D&D: Honor Among Thieves” isn’t getting as much [tumblr] love as it deserves. This is my contribution:
- Everyone involved– writer, actor, director, wardrobe, camera, EVERYONE– understood the assignment.
- There is no attempt to apologize for the fact that it’s an ensemble fantasy comedy-adventure movie.
- The plot is clever without being Too Clever. All of the major twists are well-telegraphed, and while it surprises you in a couple of places, it doesn’t try to shock you.
- Given that the archetypes of the fantasy genre came to us from Tolkein, Dungeons & Dragons, and Tolken-by-way-of-D&D, you will not need any context for the game and the lore that is not provided by the film itself. If you aren’t familiar with the lore, there are no jokes or plot points you will miss.
- If you are familiar with the Lore, there are references galore, but they’re not fan service, they’re the byproduct of the fact that the movie is set in a known location in a richly developed world. For example, despite that the fact that it’s set in Neverwinter, at no point do any characters utter the phrase “Neverwinter Nights”.
- If there must be a negative comparison to the game, it’s that no Dungeon Master alive could get a party to stick to the plot that well. They’d have gotten off track at the battlefield and the bard would have tried to seduce the Red Witch. Or everyone would have tried to adopt Themberchaud.
My mother, who understands D&D only as that loud nerd event which takes over the dining room four nights a month, loved the movie.
A fun game if you’re into D&D is to spot every Nat 1 and Nat 20. There’s a really funny Nat 1 that the sorc rolls mid way through and it’s so fucking funny.
ALSO the website of “practical effects are superior” can have a field day with this movie. There are dragonborn, tabaxi AND arakockra characters that are majority practical effects, not CGI
It is the best film approximation of the actual experience of playing D&D.
Someone rolls a nat 20 to use a potato as an improvised thrown weapon.




