Jamil and Kalim have an inherently tragic relationship
Twst is full of a lot of unique relationships and interactions. A lot of the characters aren’t friends in the traditional sense. What was the most compelling to me was the story of two boys tied together and torn apart by the society they live in.
Jamil’s family are servants to Kalim’s family. Jamil was born a servant and expected to remain a servant. He was tasked with taking care of Kalim when he was a child himself.
I see a lot of people misinterpreting the reason behind Jamil’s overblot, both not having sympathy for his past or not liking him because he’s mean and Kalim is nice. It’s not that Jamil necessarily wants to be mean; he’s an entirely different person when he’s allowed to enjoy himself or engaging in something he loves-
But 99% of the time, he’s trapped, and he knows he’s trapped.
He’s been in servitude since he was born. His own parents command that he always let Kalim win in everything they do- competitions, grades, everything. They ask their own child, who is incredibly talented and brilliant, to purposefully fail. They drill into him that Kalim is more important than him, and he gets punished for even daring to ask Kalim to play something else while they’re literally children.
All the adults around him echo the same sentiments. They know Jamil is talented and smart, but he isn’t important. He should be giving Kalim every victory that belongs to him; he should put his line on the line for Kalim constantly.
He almost died for Kalim’s sake, and with the constant assassination attempts, it’s likely that one of them might just be enough to do him in.
The main point of conflict for him is not only is he meant to suffer in silence, unable to communicate with anyone how he feels because no one cares. He’s not able to do what he wants to do or be what he wants to be…and Kalim unfortunately didn’t see this until it was too late.
Jamil has tried to communicate with Kalim subtly or even telling him up front “Please don’t do this” “Ask me first before you do something like this” and it always falls on deaf ears. Not because Kalim doesn’t care, but he doesn’t notice, and his upbringing has shielded him from noticing stuff like that.
Jamil resents Kalim for him, albeit unintentionally, being a big part of the reason why he isn’t free. Jamil’s one shot of getting to be himself by going to school overseas was diminished as soon as Kalim followed him, and so his job continued and never ends.
With Kalim, it’s an entirely different story that’s just as sad. Kalim definitely has more power in the relationship, but he’s just as powerless in the life he lives up to this point.
Kalim suffers from multiple kidnappings and multiple assassination attempts. He’s been poisoned as a child repeatedly, even poisoned by family members that want him dead just to get closer to his father’s wealth.
He didn’t do anything except be born as the eldest son and heir to a fortune.
If he can’t even trust his own family members not to kill him in painful and violent ways, then who can he trust?
Jamil was all he had. He was the only person who never attempted to poison him, who always did everyone with him (He was forced to.) Jamil always takes care of him, and always helps him (he was forced to.) Despite everything that happens to him, it is Jamil’s near-death experience on his behalf that he takes to heart.
How is a child supposed to grapple with the fact that people want him dead? Some of his family wants him dead. Jamil was probably the only person he could trust unconditionally (and even that wasn’t true)
When Jamil left for school, he likely had no one. He was left with his family members, some of whom he couldn’t fully trust, even with his optimism and desire for happiness. He wanted to be with his best friend (who was forced to be his best friend and didn’t want him there)
Even when Jamil betrayed him, Kalim was willing to just take his word for it and let it go because he would’ve believed him regardless if he knew he used him. Because Jamil wouldn’t do that.
Kalim was kept in the dark about so much. There’s a chance he doesn’t know who’s been trying to kill him; he wasn’t told that Jamil was forced to give him his accomplishments, and he didn’t know his position of housewarden was bought for him. All he knew was that Jamil was his friend and that he loved him.
They’re stuck together, Jamil wants to have freedom, and Kalim doesn’t want to let go. It’s neither of their fault their lives turned out this way. Their home has strict hierarchies.
I’m sure when they were young, very young before Jamil’s parents and other adults started enforcing certain rules, these two could play as normal. Their positions as rich heir and servant wouldn’t have mattered until it did.
Kalim can treat Jamil as a friend, he can love him with all of his big heart, but Jamil still has an obligation to take care of him. They aren’t equal as they are, so Kalim isn’t the same as a friend in Jamil’s eyes, and that’s so sad.
I always hope, if twst as a story gets to this point, that Kalim will set Jamil free like Aladdin freeing the genie, so that Jamil can experience a life owned by only himself.
Maybe someday he’ll come back, and what kept them apart as children won’t be there anymore, Kalim can have a friend, and Jamil can live his life, and they can both get past their trauma. I have so many thoughts about them, this is too long. Just manifesting any development (because Chapter 5 did have some and I love it but I needed MORE)