Caleb’s recent interview has got me worried about Lucas and Max for many reasons, but he’s also made my theory on how El and Lucas will deal with Max’s state differently even more possible.
I have a feeling that at some point, Lucas will accept to himself that Max is gone forever, and that conclusion will lead him to spend season 5 with the party rather than in the hospital with Max.
For Lucas, believing Max is gone is probably the best thing he can do for himself. He’s always been a skeptic, and after all he’s gone though, I don’t see him having an optimistic approach to Max’s state.
I believe El will be on the side of there is a way to get Max back, and will be the one who’s storyline revolves around that and trying to use Max’s state to gain useful information on how to fight Vecna.
I’m not sure if these opposing views will stir any conflict between Lucas and El though. The two seem to be in a place where even these completely different outlooks would not anger the other. They are the two people who understand each others pain the most and will most likely accept that the way they feel is the best way for them to handle it.
We see this exact thought process in season 1 with Lucas’s acceptance that Will is dead. He sees a body and he’s decided to focus of working though grief rather than what he thinks may be denial. The doctors tell him that she might not wake up, and I assume he believes it’s very possible and as time passes he will probably be more sure. He trusts facts and knows that grieving would be more helpful for him that putting all his energy into something he can’t do.
El on the other hand is the person that literally revived Max with the thought process “we make our own rules”. She does not trust doctors and will probably dismiss their predictions not based on delusions, but based on her own sense of fact. That being that she literally brought her friend back from the dead. A coma couldn’t be that hard could it?
I have a LOT more thoughts and predictions for Max’s arc in season 5 and how it could directly help the gang defeating vecna, as well as a really interesting was I’d love to see her be able to communicate with El while still being unable to interact as a fully conscious person. If you are interested to hear those thoughts let me know!