i 100% agree and i find it mind blowing how many women insist that this is an improvement. WHY do you want her to be a victim? WHY do you want to see more sexual violence inflicted on her? WHY do you want that extremely intelligent and shrewd, politically astute woman to be reduced to a bumbling fool?
show!alicent is a terrible politician, in spite of what everyone says about how she is so much better than rhaenyra at playing the game. this scene all but cements it:
during the small council meeting, there is a mention of blackwoods and brackens having a conflict (as they always do, lol). alicent says that this is not the concern of the crown.
she knows this because she saw it with her own eyes during her betrothal tour. i think they were in storm's end when that little guy and a bracken dickhead started an argument and the guy killed him.
alicent scoffs at this. why? two noble houses, known for having beef that goes back centuries, are at each other's throats again. it is within the crown's competence to solve this.
then tyland addresses the stepstones.
rhaenyra says that the stepstones was not fortified enough and that's why the situation is unstable.
alicent of course has to go against rhaenyra no matter what.
and that's true, raising taxes to build fortifications would strain the crown less than another war in the stepstones. because of course it would.
lastly, rhaenyra comes with a proposal that would end the wedge between the two branches of house targaryen and make helaena a literal queen of the seven kingdoms.
this is an excellent match, one that would put alicent's blood on the throne, just one generation later. what does alicent do? you know what.
show!alicent in episodes 6-7 operates solely on spite, on undermining rhaenyra any chance she has, thus her political prowess is nonexistent. episodes 8-9 alicent regresses back to being otto's pawn, is the queen of the seven kingdoms but can't build a reliable network of spies, does not have her own ambitions and is just a mindless pawn of otto, zero intelligence, zero shrewdness, just endless naivety and idiocy. this is your queen? this is your nuanced character?
every other fandom would've rebelled if a woman was reduced to a passive victim subjected to sexual violence AND an idiot at that. here this is hailed as nuance, her victimhood is celebrated, her idiocy put on a pedestal. why?