SUICIDE SQUAD review by Steve Oatney —
Or, a better question: Is Suicide Squad dark enough? While I must admit that this was one of my favorite DC Comics’ movies, in a long time, Suicide Squad is still nowhere near on par with the powerful storytelling of The Dark Knight (2008).
Why isn’t this new dark comic-book movie just what the doctor ordered? It seems that the tastes of comic-fan audiences have perhaps changed so much, in recent years, that they now need Superman to be as dark as Batman, and furthermore film studios are now exploring even darker avenues, or “back-alleyways,” as in Suicide Squad. Exactly how can we expect portrayed villains to be ominous, fearsome, and terrifying when our protagonists fit firmly in those categories, as well?
Decades ago, characters like Marvel’s Wolverine, in the X-Men comics, helped to change the playing-field arena, redefining what a hero is, and what separates them from a villain. The line continues to blur, bringing us to Suicide Squad. A team of “heroes” made up of some of the worst criminals in the entire world! I’d like to explore this new darker direction in comic-books and comic-book films, just a bit, so please bear with me...
Comic-book film genre competitor Marvel Entertainment’s R-rated Deadpool broke the mold for big-screen superheroes who, clearly, no longer need to adhere to the goody-two-shoes, squeaky-clean, law-abiding hero archetype from days of yore. Deadpool cursed up a storm, had deviant-style sex on-screen, and sliced and diced baddies like the super-Cuisinart that he is. Why am I writing so much about Deadpool in a review about Suicide Squad? Well, in a nutshell, I feel strongly that SS absolutely should have been made with an R-rating target in mind.
Based upon the main character descriptions, alone, SS in an adult story meant for us grown-ups. Sorry moms and dads, but some comic-books and some comic-book movies are NOT meant for your kids. Sadly, motion picture companies like Warner Bros are still often more interested in putting butts in seats than doing what is right for their characters and stories. Case in point, SS’s PG-13 rating.
Let me elaborate; Harley Quinn, played in SS by Margot Robbie, was originally introduced in a cartoon in 1992 called Batman: The Animated Series. Her villainous character developed over time, in DC comic books, and became more sexualized and violent. Warner Bros definitely hit tilt on the sexiness-meter with her scantily-clad costume in the Suicide Squad movie, but she, and the rest of the squad would have been better served, if they were served-up to us on an R-rated platter where they could take things to the Deadpool-level. Yes, it is true, kiddies, Deadpool has set a new bar, and a pretty high one at that, for adult-targeted comic-book movie storytelling. In my humble opinion, if the WB had Deadpooled Suicide Squad, they would have begun to scratch the surface of sheer greatness.
Alas, I’m finding it difficult to give Suicide Squad an “A” grade. In fact, it is only because the acting was so well done, as were the special effects, that I don’t give it a worse grade. I’d give SS a grade of “B-.” Considering that I’d give Man of Steel (2013) and Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice (2016) even lower grades, that means that SS is actually near the top of my list of DC Comics’ movies, in recent years. Not counting The Dark Knight, I, literally, have to go all the way back to 1989’s Batman and 1978’s Superman: The Movie to find better DC films, which is sort of sad, when you think about it.
Science-fiction fans continue to go ape, these days, for comic-books turned into movies. The last decade has seen more comic movies released than ever before, and ticket sales still continue to skyrocket for this genre. With that, now comes an abundance of comparisons to what fans consider great comic-book films. My short-list of favorites includes films like The Dark Knight (2008), Iron Man (2008), and The Avengers (2012). People seem to be curious about how long this “fad” will last. How many more blockbuster record-breaking comic-book movies are there left to make? Apparently, a lot.
There is no sign of slowing, nor stopping, any time soon. Both Warner Bros and Marvel Entertainment have long lists of films-to-come on into the heroic horizon. Still, if they want to continue to break records for years to come, it will all hinge on storytelling and character-development. Directors matter. Actors matter. Special-effects teams matter. Loads of behind-the-scenes crew-members matter, but it all comes down to a great story being told by great storytellers.
Suicide Squad’s story was good, but not great. The acting actually was pretty great, on all counts, but it was often hidden under piles of special-effects and battle-scenes. For me, the best parts of the film were the setups. The get-to-know portions of the film, focusing on the main characters whom most of us know little about. Will Smith’s character, Deadshot, trying to be a good father to his young daughter while also having a career as an elite sniper assassin with many kills under his belt. The backstory of Margot Robbie’s character, Harley Quinn, who is a psychiatrist turned criminal by The Joker. The Joker, well played by Jared Leto, was more of a side-character and not part of the actual squad. His eerie portrayal of the well known and well loved villain would have likely been regarded as the best Joker of all time, if it weren’t for Heath Ledger’s legendary role. Viola Davis’ character, Amanda Waller, stood out as a tough-as-nails government official who puts the team together and lords over them with an iron fist.
The rest of the squad, played by Cara Delevigne (The Enchantress), Jay Hernandez (Diablo), Jai Courtney (Capt. Boomerang), Adewale Akinnouye-Agbaje (Killer Croc), Joel Kinnaman (Rick Flag), and Adam Beach (Slipknot), also contributed performances in fine style. Not to mention the appearances of Barry Allen/The Flash played by Ezra Miller and and Bruce Wayne/Batman played by Ben Affleck… helping to interconnect the multiple films in which they will cross-over in the coming years.
What do you think? Is it enough to simply put a team of criminals together to fight national, international, and otherworldly threats? Was Suicide Squad dark enough for your taste and/or expectations? Is PG-13 the right rating for such a film? For my money, I’d prefer to go even deeper into the criminal, and criminally-insane, minds of SS’s unconventional and deeply-disturbed characters. THAT is where the story is. Go there! Live there! Write the script from inside THAT box, and then take it way way way outside that box! I have a feeling that potential spin-off films for Harley Quinn or The Joker (or the both of them together) could delve into the wildly deranged plans and actions of fewer characters at a time, and therefore suffer less the incoherent and somewhat hodge-podged story arc of Suicide Squad.
Looking forward, I hope that DC and Warner Bros can make their future films like Wonder Woman and Justice League great, and perhaps give the most iconic superheroes, in the world, the top-notch portrayals that they so rightly deserve. In my opinion it is a travesty, the lack of Wonder Woman shows and movies over the last four decades! The world’s single most recognizable female superhero deserves nothing less than over-the-top greatness! That… is another story...