Just finished watching The Outcast on my rewatch of tng.
It's a hard episode to watch now, though I don't remember the last time I saw it. One thing that I wonder about is whether Soren was lying to Riker when she told him she wanted to stay. My personal feeling is that she was. She knew what would or could happen to him if he brought her off the planet and wasn't willing to let him make that sacrifice for her.
It's obvious that the story is supposed to be a tragedy, and that the tragedy is that Soren's society doesn't actually give her a choice. In the context of when the episode was written and aired, that was more true for queer folks than it is today. That's something that I think people may not always give enough credit for when talking about this episode (that and I can't remember when the rating boards changed the policy on gays not being allowed to have happy endings).
So it's a tragedy, and part of it is that she was in a position where her only choices were sacrificing everything about herself or sacrificing everything about the man she loved.
It would have been wonderful to get a happy ending there, with Soren leaving with Riker or being rescued by the other people like her. But in some ways, it would have cheapened the story. The way it is, it's a call to think about the ways that society deeply harms queer folks, and the impossible situations we get put in.
But on the whole, the writing for the episode was beautifully done. If I knew more about film I'd say something about the way it was staged and shot as well, because I think that was excellent too.
And as an aside, I really appreciated the little bit of off-screen character growth we get for Worf. It's clear to me that his exchange with his friends at their poker night made him rethink his assumptions and changed his mind. That's a little detail that's actually really important in the episode, because Worf is the most "macho" of the men on the ship.
Honestly though, my favorite thing about it on this watching was knowing that Jonathan Frakes tried really hard to get them to cast a male actor as Soren. That just really warms my heart.










