See that’s the thing that gets me about Edelgard: she didn’t come to Garreg Mach to make friends.
Well yeah, you might be saying. She was planning to start a war.
But no. No! We’re not talking about the other houses. Yes, of course Edelgard had no intention of making friends with the people she would soon make enemies of. That part is obvious.
But Edelgard didn’t come to Garreg Mach to make friends with her own house.
Dimitri, he’s surrounded by kids he grew up with, people he’s known all his life. The Blue Lions all have a long history with each other and with their prince. Even the ones outside of his immediate circle have connections to him, and all of them have at least some understanding of his history.
But Edelgard? Edelgard never knew any of the Black Eagles other than Hubert.
Edelgard came to Garreg Mach not just to declare war on the church, but to dissolve the noble class. And these kids, her own house, were mostly the sons and daughters of the very people she planned to strip power from. Hevring and Bergliez were convinced to side with her, but Aegir and Varley? Ferdinand and Bernadetta could have posed as much of a threat to her plans as any enemy.
For that matter, being “allies” hardly would have made Caspar and Lindhardt trustworthy either, given both that their own houses were happy to participate in the Insurrection of the Seven and they wouldn’t be the only allies Edelgard has who she doesn’t remotely trust.
For all she knew, the other Black Eagles were all spies or enemies or at the very least, privileged noble kids who would never agree to her plan to dissolve the system that they benefitted from. For that matter, any one of them could have been like Monica, just a Slither in disguise. It’s ironic that Petra, a foreign hostage, was likely the only person that Edelgard could accept at face value.
And none of them knew her. None of them knew of her history, or her plans, or her second crest.
But here’s the thing. They accepted her. They had fun with her. They studied together, they planned competitions together, they danced together, they slept down the hall from one another. For the first time in her memory, Edelgard got to be among her peers. She got to have friends. And not like Hubert was her friend – he served her and he conspired with her and he loved her as only a best friend can, but for years their friendship had revolved around a dark purpose. These were friends without pretence, without goals, who treated her as an equal without politics or backstabbing.
For the first time ever, Edelgard got to be a teenager.
It’s no wonder she treats her house like a precious thing. Why, after they agreed to side with her despite all her efforts to push them away and give them a choice, she stayed up all night to come up with the name Black Eagles Strike Force. Because she never planned, never dreamed, of being part of something so good, and she never wants to let it go.