Do you know how much thought I put into my fanfics?
Fanfics are the place I use to improve my writing. I challenge myself and edit. Then edit again. I cut things that aren’t working. I read them out loud to minimize typos. I put as much time, thought, and effort in to the creation of my fanfics and I would a real novel.
It’s disrespectful because you are basically just saying, without an author’s knowledge nor permission, to their free work, their work they poured effort into and shared with you 100% for free, “I want a machine to do this instead, and I think a machine could do this just as well.”
My last fic was 150,000 words and took 2 years to finish. I am still actively editing it so I can get it bound into a hardcover for myself and my friends because I am that proud of it. I have probably spent, as only a rough estimate, not even counting the other connected stories, about 300 hours on a free legend of zelda fic. If I - or any author, including of professional published works - worked at $10 an hour, a well-below livable wage, my book would be worth $3,000.
A machine will never be able to do what a good writer will do, and it is dangerous to feed into the notion that they can. This is not me exaggerating and being lovey dovey about the power of artists and human beings. This is a fact. Machines cannot think or reason. Under no circumstances do we ever WANT a machine that can think and reason the way a human can. Writing is not just words on the page and how they fit together. Here is a non-exhaustive list of things I consider as a writer:
- setting
- pacing, including what parts of my story warrant long description and entire scenes, and which parts should be transitioned through quickly
- symbolism, including which symbols should be worked in throughout the entire novel (this often includes going back and adding in things that weren’t there before)
- character development
- character arcs
- dialogue (including what words characters would actually say and what things they are leaving out)
- how to connect the beginning of the book to the end of the book
- what i am promising the reader they will experience as part of the plot’s journey
- is my plot living up to said promise? what elements are making it so?
- What elements of the story are currently too distracting and taking away from the effect of the book?
- What emotions, questions, thoughts, and feelings do I want the reader to be left with in every chapter and at the end of the book
- What choice of words I am using to create those emotions for the reader?
- Subtext
- Voice of the narrator, or my own writing voice
- And more!
About 10% of those are about how words fit together on the page. Do you seriously expect a machine that just eats information to learn how to string words together pretty will be able to do all that? AI recognizes patterns that are on the surface. AI cannot analyze everything that goes on in the human mind, both from the writer’s and the reader’s perspective.
If you want a certain type of fic you can’t find, write it yourself. Feeding writing into machines to get “good results,” to “train” this AI into making better writing, will never work. AI will never actually be able to do so, and to become complacent in allowing society to believe that AI can do all these things will lead to the further abuse of all writers and continued devaluation of our medium. Writers put in more work than they will ever be fairly compensated for, and you want it that way.
Do not use AI. Especially do not use AI if you want to keep seeing good work. Not just about the work that the AI generates, but the actual books, movies, tv shows around you. It is not a coincidence AI writing is getting attention while a major writer’s strike is going on. Every time you use AI and feed a good piece of writing into it, you are telling the people who want to replace writers that it CAN work and they absolutely should. You are telling them you WANT them to invest more time, money, and effort into making these machines “better,” and in fact, to prove it, you just stole something and fed it to it yourself!
I cannot stop people from feeding work into AI. I unfortunately cannot stop my own work from being fed into AI. But if we do not take a stand against this, writers will stop writing. People will get replaced. New works will stop being born. Wonderful things will never even have the chance to come to life because “a machine could do it anyway.” And that is bleak, my fucking dude.