Oh, that video (22:41 minutes long). The one people constantly spam recommend in my comments. The one they seem to think is a gotcha when it doesn't address any of the points we are making. That one.
A lot of the things it says aren't really wrong. Yes, Catra is a product of her abuse. Yes, her toxic behavior is born out of need to protect herself from further heartbreak. Yes, she needs care and support in order to change. None of this is new to me but it's not wrong either.
However, the essay completely fails to acknowledge Catra as not only a victim of abuse, but a perpetrator of it.
Her wrongdoings are dismissed as a hurt child lashing out when many of them were deliberate, cold-blooded acts of cruelty. The fact that she never had to truly face the consequences of her actions is neatly dodged with talks about how scorn and hatred won't solve anything, as though accountability cannot co-exist with compassion.
I'm not saying everyone should go out of their way to be mean to Catra as some form of retribution. I'm saying that the characters Catra hurt shouldn't have their trauma brushed aside all for the sake of making her redemption run smoother. Glimmer should be allowed to mourn her mother. Entrapta should be allowed to have nightmares about that time she was put on a murder island and sapped of her will to live. Scorpia should be allowed to feel betrayed. Adora should be allowed to acknowledge the absolute hell Catra put her through instead of forgetting about it to blush at her goddamn claws.
Even people who did horrible things deserve kindness, true. But — and that's the part everyone likes to ignore in this argument — said kindness shouldn't come from the same people they did horrible things TO. Of course, some victims can choose to forgive and even help their former abuser on a journey of recovery. Yet we mustn't forget that the victims in question are fictional characters, and therefore their “choices” are actually the writers' creative choices.
When a female character “chooses” to wear impractical sexualized clothing with the most shoddy excuse, it's actually the writers choosing to objectify her.
When every single person hurt by this character “chooses” to forgive them as soon as they do something good for once, it's actually the writers choosing to minimize the amount of work that has to put into their redemption.
The author is making statements like these:
“Catra is traumatized by a childhood characterized by intimidation, manipulation, and verbal and physical abuse”
…while supporting a relationship similarly characterized by intimidation, manipulation, and verbal and physical abuse, even hearting comments that claim anyone who doesn't support it is not an actual abuse victim.
Another example of them playing down the harm Catra caused to her “love interest”:
“and eventually, she returns the kindness Adora showed to her on the ship, asking her what she wants”
Conveniently forgetting to mention that she also pushed her to the ground 10 seconds before, followed by leaving her alone to die despite Adora's desperate pleas. Aka the exact OPPOSITE of what Adora did for her on the ship.
This is the result of Catra's kindness, apparently.
In short, the perspective provided by this video is not incorrect, but it's a one-sided, incomplete, and as a result dangerously misleading perspective.
Sure, they're not lying. But they're leaving out chunks of important information that completely re-contextualize the conclusion they want their audience to reach.
Catra matters. What this fandom needs to learn is that she's not the only one who does.
(Funnily enough, OP also has a Why Adora Matters video (26:08), which I'd rather not waste my time on, but five bucks says they go into every minute detail of the abuse she suffered from Shadow Weaver while carefully glossing over the same abuse tactics Catra uses and citing Season 5 to prove she's actually good for Adora. You can watch for yourself and see if I'm right.)