Speaking as someone who has been being told I was “gifted” by schools since I was literally in preschool and who grew up to fail out of his college engineering program and consequentially suffer from the worst mental breakdown of his life, i fucking hate the assumption that all smart kids want and need to be challenged
Which translates in a school setting as “take the hardest and most demanding classes you can possibly take”
I distinctly remember always been pushed by my teachers to take the highest available level of all of my courses, and the few times that I resisted and decided to take an easier one they would shame me. They told me I was “better than that”, or expressed disappointment in me. In particular I remember one of my favorite teachers doing it when I said I didn’t want to take honors history and was politely declining the recommendation
I fucking HATE history. I had so much else going on in my life during that time besides just school. Why would I want to make it even harder for myself? Why would I want the extra load of stress and work? Just because, at the expense of my happiness and mental health, I could do it?
Like so many other students in the US I have grown used to watching my classmates sob and have panic attacks over exams and classes and school in general. That’s become disturbingly normal to us. And then people have the audacity to look at a student who actually has time to live and relax and not be constantly stressed out and say they aren’t “pushing themselves hard enough”. They should take more classes, or harder classes
And I fell for it. Growing up surrounded by that expectation of me I originally went into the college of engineering. You know why? Because I was smart. Because it was the hardest of the hard, and because I could do it, I was obligated to
And I couldn’t do it. I’m not the kind of person who can handle engineering. I have the intelligence, but I don’t have the personality or the mental health. The people who do? Fantastic. I’m happy for them and thankful they exist. But I’m not one of them, and I had to learn that it was okay that I wasn’t