3.11 ends just after 9:30am on Monday. A half hour before Nathan returns to Richmond at 10am, Monday.
I can't imagine I'm the only one who assumed 3.12 would pick up right where 3.11 left off. We would see Ted tell Rebecca he's leaving. We would see Nathan arrive at 10am for his first day back in a fraught work environment. We would see him and Ted finally talk.
We don't see any of those things.
Instead, 3.12 jumps to ahead to a morning some time later.
The show skips the central conversations the season has been leading up to in favor of teasing Tedbecca one last time.
The writing prioritized being a petty little asshole to Tedbecca shippers over providing a meaningful (ONSCREEN) resolution to the Nathan-Ted conflict.
I get the appeal of being a petty little asshole. It's a rewarding experience. But look at what was sacrificed. At who was once again sacrificed.
The opening of 3.12 was not a particularly kind parting gift for the Tedbecca shippers. I can see why they would be upset.
Even though I don't ship Ted and Rebecca together (or with anyone, really), I'm upset, too. I resent the scene for what it replaced (an important moment for Nathan) and what it enabled (Nathan being assistant to the kitman).
To show rather than tell would have required an actual in-character, earned, and sensical reason for Nathan to return as anything other than a coach (the thing 3.11 was teasing).
Showing would have required someone to believably say, "I know Nathan is more than qualified to be an assistant coach. I know that he has the skills, experience, and insight into West Ham (as their former manager) that would enable us to win the whole fucking thing. But I think it would be best if he served in the lowest-ranking position in the locker room instead. Rather than use Nathan's coaching genius, Richmond should invent a new position that will allow Nathan to serve under someone with vastly less kitman experience. That is a thing that should happen."
Someone (possibly even Nathan) would have to say that, and other people would have to agree.
Showing would require multiple characters to agree, "Yes, the best place for the only Brown coach on this show is to serve and clean up after the people he once supervised and who once bullied him. This is the right thing, because this Brown man needs to practice humility, be punished with manual labor, prove his devotion to a two billion pound club, and/or take comfort in repetitive tasks. This is an incredibly generous offer."
The Tedbecca fake-out allowed the show to avoid
- Explaining a non-sensical plot twist/reversal
- Justifying one of the most racist writing choices on an already racist show
- Showing beloved white characters putting Nathan in his place--one final racist act that may (finally) tarnish their benevolent white reputations
The Tedbecca fake-out was a distraction. It demonstrated tremendous contempt for the fans, and it denied both Nathan and Nick Mohammed a well-deserved opportunity to shine.