Avatar

@aoncelikethat

💜

Hogwarts Legacy Review - by a mixed-race woman with Jewish roots.

So I've been playing about 12h total I guess, I'm level 13 now and Ravenclaw.

  • Graphics: I was surprised to find my laptop doesn't do too well if I don't put the graphics at low quality, but that's all right. I didn't buy my laptop for gaming, and actually even in low settings I am so amazed by how astonishing everything looks. Also it looks so artistic, like paintings? It's just so beautiful!
  • Open world: It's massive. MASSIVE. But the map tools are fantastic, so you really don't get lost and if you did, there are thousand ways to find your way.
  • Similarity to books/films: So they've taken A LOT of creative freedoms, which is great, because it provides another option, if you catch my drift. There are areas of the castle that look like an absolute palace, compared to the official Potter videogames that were less stunning, and areas wild and green and gorgeous, and some areas of the castle are in a different place than you'd expect, same with Hogsmeade, but like I said, the map tool is just fantastic so it's fine.
  • Story being anti-semitic? So, careful with the spoiler, but the TRA people spent I don't know how long saying the game was some anti-Semitic horrible thing because Rowling is apparently anti-Semitic (so these jerks say) and the main plot is wizards-vs-goblins-who-apparently-repressent-jews. OK let me debunk this for you. One, the plot is there's an evil allegiance between some wizards and some goblins, and so then there's a good allegiance between the other wizards and the other goblins. You'll find a ton of goblins who need your help and a very scarce minority of bad goblins (and I'm currently stuck on one of these missions btw). But the majority of goblins are villagers and innocent gents like that. And goblins are not Jews. I've read about a good bunch of Jews who are not finding any issues with this videogame, and personally, between me and the Jewish community I'm in, of those of us playing, no one, so far, has felt even slightly offended by anything. And we know Rowling to be allied with several Jewish friends of hers, to have stood for Jews multiple times, and that in Potter, Voldemort repressented Hitler and Hermione and other "mudbloods", the Jews. That's the only repressentation of Jews I care about by this author, and I believe it led millions of children back then to better understanding anti-Semitism and what happened with Nazism.
  • LGBT-friendliness: It's as friendly as it could possibly be. You get trans characters, I've already found a lesbian marriage as well, and when you create your character you can choose which loos they use (which I find a bit absurd because you don't have a need to go to the loo at all), and you can wear any hairstyle regardless of your sex. Facial hair, for what I've seen, is not available (you're supposed to be 15, so it makes sense) and clothes, because it's 19th century, are quite different sometimes depending on sex. But you've got a massive variety of clothes, so you can probably find something that suits you either way. Personally, I've loved all of the clothing options I've found.
  • Canon: So far I've only recognised some surnames from the books. Everything else is not from the books and their own invention. Quite imaginative!
  • Difficulty levels: So you can choose between, if I remember correctly, Very easy, easy, normal, and difficult (or something like that). I'll probably end up lowering my difficulty level because I'm so rusty with videogames!
  • Quidditch: It's been cancelled by the headmaster, but you can still fly broomsticks around the massive open world and other animals.
  • Animal interaction: you'll love it.
  • Character mobility: You can swim, jump, walk, dodge, run, swim faster, dive, climb up things... Pretty much everything you'd normally do.
  • Castle secrets: So, so many. I'm making a massive use of Revelio left and right, quite entertaining!
  • Spells and combat: So you get many duelling opportunities, and duelling has never (and I've played every Potter videogame to date) been so realistic and fun. It's incredibly wild, savage, you really have to improve your coordination and make sure to get familiar with your console or keyboard. You get many spells, keep unlocking more as you go, and the visual effects are jaw-dropping.
  • Glitches: To everyone complaining about glitches, you just really need a decent place to game in. I'm doing it in PC and it's not a gaming PC, but also it's not your average PC, and it does quite well with graphics left as recommended by my graphics card. I had a couple minor glitches that disappeared shortly after on their own.
  • What you missed from the films: WE HAVE PEEVES!!! And keep your eye out because he's a little devil. You also have access to classes, your own place to brew potions in your spare time, same for planting things, and so on.
  • Relationships and interaction: There's no romance, but there's so much interaction. There's friendship, you can choose to have people duelling in your side with you, and as you walk around you'll constantly hear voices of people around you, and there will always be stuff going on. I went to the Quidditch pitch and found a group of players from my house complaining about the headmaster, then losing a quaffle, and then going to fetch it. And it wasn't on loop, it was very natural. Then around the castle the ghosts will say things, students... Lots going on! lots of life!
  • Accesibility: All voices are both on subtitles and in your ears, you can change language as well, and brightness and things like that. They do warn people who might suffer seizures from epilepsia.
  • Shopping: So you'll find money all over, and then you can buy clothes, haircuts, lots of things. And when you buy clothes it has this super cool option where you can choose one item because it gives you more defence or attack points, but give it the appearance of any other you got that you might like more. Magic!
  • Multi-racial representation / sexism: So far very good. My house partner is Asian I think, but I've quite befriended Gryffindor's girl, who's from Tanzania I think? Well, she went to the African school and mentions a fictitious town she lived in with her Mum. The only white character is the Slytherin boy I believe (can't remember who was in Hufflepuff). And as for random students / teachers, you really get massive diversity. It's like walking around London for me. Also, about as many important males as females, which is great.
  • About that trans character! So Sirona is named after the Celtic goddess of healing and I find the name quite fitting. She manages the Three Broomsticks (can't remember if they give it another name in the videogame though), and is this heroic warrior who helps you massively through a tricky moment and basically saves your arse.

Anyway, if there's any specific question about the game you've got, I'm here!

Avatar

My Thoughts on Hogwarts Legacy

This is something that has been on my mind recently as more discourse about the topic is coming to the forefrunt of the internet. Hogwarts Legacy and, honestly, the Harry Potter franchise as a whole.

As I see things, there are 5 groups of people when it comes to "THAT wizard game."

  1. "Hey, I don't want to play it because of my own personal reasons. But if you want to play it, I hope you have fun."
  2. "Hey, I do want to play this game because of my own, personal reasons, but I understand that you're not interested. That's cool."
  3. "This game gives money to a transphobe?! Awesome! I just bought two copies."
  4. "You want to play this game for your own reasons? You're a transphobe piece of shit. I won't stop until you know you're a piece of shit."
  5. "Harry Potter? Hogwarts Legacy? I haven't played video games since I lost 2 weeks of my life to Banjo Kazooie in 1998."

If you fall into either category 1, 2, or 5, then right on. You're doing the right thing. Keep it up.

However, if you fall into either category 3 or 4, you are a fucking problem and you need to cut the shit and grow up.

Personally, I fall into category 1. I feel I have made my views on the game and franchise fairly clear. But also, I have a good friend who learned to read because of Harry Potter. I grew up with the franchise and it was a huge part of my childhood, and recognizing that I no longer want to engage in the franchise felt like a huge loss to me, and took some time to reconcile with myself. But, again, I have made that decision based on the larger franchise and not simply this one game. And, also again, these are my OWN PERSONAL REASONS. If you're interested, I will gladly share my thoughts in a civil manner, and only ask that you understand my thinking, not that you agree with me, or try to convince me to change my mind.

Now, to address category 3. Deep breath, here.

If you are doing anything at all because you know it will make the lives of people worse, then fuck you right to hell. Yes, this group of people also generally goes hand in hand with a specific red hat and an orange demagogue. If you find yourself in this category, get help. Go to therapy and ask about this concept called "empathy."

Category 4.

I will repeat: if you are doing anything at all because you know it will make the lives of people worse, then fuck you right to hell. Setting up websites to track Twitch streamers to see who is playing Hogwarts Legacy? Going to channels and harrassing the streamers for wanting to play the game? I would argue that people in this category or worse than those in category 3 because while those in 3 as assholes, they are blowing money on something they don't actually care about to try triggering someone while people in this group are going out and actively attacking people for engaging something that they want to experience for, and repeat after me, THEIR OWN PERSONAL REASONS. I saw in one chat that someone mentioned they wished executions were legal because people were doing something they didn't like. Sounds an awful lot like some people who built some gallows outside of a notable large building in the US back in the beginning of January 2021, doesn't it?

Here's where things really boil down on Hogwarts Legacy. The game is made. It's done. Rowling has been paid or will be getting paid. You attacking people for enjoying the game isn't going to stop that. But there's a lot more people than just her in the mix, here. Think about all the hundreds of people who have spent YEARS working on making this game, and trying to make it the best game possible. They have also been paid and are continuing to get paid. Controversy has surrounded Hogwarts Legacy pretty much since it was announced. And it wasn't cancelled.

Here's where I see things going with the game: it is the outrage of the day. Somewhat surprisingly, the outrage of Hogwarts Legacy's release is overshadowing the much more recent information about Justin Roiland. People will continue to be upset by this game for a while, and eventually that will fade, as all outrage does.

But you know what won't pass? The hurt caused by people to other people over this game. Your friend, who you disagree with about the game, sitting in their home, playing the game, is not going to hurt you. Streamer playing the game and you don't want to watch it? THEN FUCKING DON'T. Full stop. For fuck's sake, people were buying subs to a twitch stream just so they could continue harrassing the streamers after they made the chat sub-only. Fuck you. Grow up. And like I told the people in group 3, get therapy.

Actually, everyone should go to therapy, but that isn't the point of this.

Here's what my point of view boils down to: let people enjoy what they enjoy and stop shitting on things just because people enjoy them. Yes, the situation here is more complex and nuanced than that, but every situation is. And if any part of this rambling has made you angry or upset for any reason, I'd like you to think about why that is. I am not advocating for people to play the game or not play the game. Honestly, I just couldn't give a fuck what you want to play in the privacy of your own home. I just want people to be better. Treat people better. Be better people. Recognize that everyone on this planet is, at the very least, deserving of being treated like a person and deserving of love. And if you can't understand that fact, did you really understand Harry Potter at all?