@maya-why The primary objective of caste-based reservations is not for economic upliftment. That is simply a by-product and consequence. The primary goal of caste based reservation is to guarantee representation of the community that has been denied representation in the public field, has been denied basic human rights.
A poor Brahmin is hampered by economic disadvantage. A poor Dalit is hampered by economic and social disadvantages. A poor Brahmin student does not run the risk of being denied food, water and companionship by their peers. Even a rich Dalit student runs the risk of being ostracized and bullied far more than their upper caste peers. Dalits and STs face some of the highest suicide rates in India. Rohith Vemula, Dr Payal Tadvi, Darshan Solanki, these are not merely coincidences.
Also, your argument about reservations on the basis of economic background is moot because even today in India, the wealth distribution is determined by one's caste. Only 22.3% of upper caste Hindus hold over 40% of the country's wealth while 7.8 per cent of Hindu Scheduled Tribes own only 3.7 per cent. The share of wage labourers among SCs was 63% (2011-12 NSSO statistics). 32% of the casual labourers in the country are SCs when their total population share is 16%.
Caste IS linked to one's socioeconomic background. This is because caste has been weaponized to maintain the status quo by upper caste, landowning Hindus. SC households own merely 9.5% of the total land in India and the average land each SC household owned was half of that owned by 'other' households.
In other words, if you feel that caste based reservations are unjust, then remember that they exist because systematic, caste based discrimination still exists in the country. Maybe you don't see it because your privilege makes the discrimination invisible. But I promise you, it is there. If you want caste based reservations to end in India, then first fight for ending caste based discrimination in India.
[image description: screenshot of two replies by tumblr user maya-why. Trascript as follows: “Also, in regard to the reservations, I think basing it off of caste exclusively is inefficient, because there's people of other caste who need it more than people who get reserved seats. A better way would be to base it off of economic strength or general socio-economic status rather than the caste background. This would guarantee help to everyone in need rather than just people of a single community. 3/4
“Ultimately the goal must be to support and uplift each other and not to spread hate and vitriol against each other. We are the future generation and it is pointless to hate each other, we already live in a society that doesn't respect the youth, we don't have to become like them. 4/4″ End image description]


























