Avatar

I will always stand with Amber Heard

@alicenttully

white/female/twenties/bisexual

I hope they keep the "bastard blood, shed at war" line in the show.

I do understand people's bewilderment at Alicent mentioning their illegitimacy (there's a time and a place). I do get that if you happen to sympathise with Rhaenyra, this could easily be seen as audacious behaviour from Alicent. But just as I think people miss the point that Alicent was making about Jacaerys and Lucerys being two dragonriders that Rhaenyra herself let (if reluctantly) join her campaign whereas Jaehaerys was a defenceless seven year old who was killed while going to bed - I think people also miss another important reason as to why Alicent says this.

Even though they're both dead and Alicent is a captive by this point and has nothing to gain from it apart from threats of mutilation, she still refuses to swallow the fiction of their birth- or at least what she sincerely believes to be a lie. Fire and Blood is styled like a history book, and because we don't get first - hand accounts from Rhaenyra, we don't know if the rumors were true. (But let's be real, they were. George wrote it in a way that made it wayyy more likely that Harwin was the father. I think if he wanted to make the Strong boys' parentage ambiguous he could have had them all take after Rhaenyra and Laenor's Valyrian colouring while still keeping the open secret of Laenor's sexuality and Rhaenyra's closeness/attraction to Harwin Strong.)

The show is different in that it had Rhaenyra admit to Daemon that none of her sons are Laenor's. But what I find more interesting is that by episode 1.08, it is heavily implied that Jacaerys and Lucerys know it too. It's never said outright, nor do I think it ever was once during the time jump because doing so even just amongst themselves would have felt too dangerous. But them knowing the truth does add an interesting dimension. Jacaerys and Lucerys die fighting for their mother's incredibly shaky claim (if you're basing the Dance off the Anarchy, then yes it is shaky sorry) but by extension they also die fighting for their own claims - which according to the rules of their society, they have no right to. It is the same rules that they would enforce. There IS a hypocrisy, and as much as I do agree with @lemonhemlock when they say that it's annoying/unfair that only Rhaenyra's children with Daemon got to live, I think it is telling that all three of the sons that she intended to inherit after her all ended up being killed. The son of hers that does end up inheriting the Iron Throne after her death is the trueborn Aegon the Younger, but it's as Aegon II's heir.

So from Alicent's perspective... it is very possible that in her anger, she made the comments because she believed Jacaerys and Lucerys died fighting for something they knew didn't belong to them, and thus their deaths were deserved/be seen as narrative punishment to the reader. Why should she feel sorry for two people who in her eyes, would be usurpers?

I hate it when you have to wait for bad news that you just know is coming. I just want to get it over with.

Avatar

Samwell Tarly is objectively the best character in ASoIaF. Genuinely tries to be a good person at every step of the journey, only member of the Night's Watch to even try to help a single one of Craster's daughters (Jon Snow could never), literally has the highest kill ratio of Others for any single man at the Wall, also a nerd. He even invented voter fraud.

Arya Stark when she learn Arya Stark is married to Ramsay Bolton:

Image

She actually has already, technically.

"They found her too," said Polliver. "The sister. She's for Bolton's bastard, I hear."

Arya sipped her wine so they could not see her mouth. She didn't understand what Polliver was talking about. Sansa has no other sister. Sandor Clegane laughed aloud.

She just misinterprets what Polliver is saying by thinking that he's referring to another girl and not realising that he is in fact talking about "her". Furthermore, even if Arya did realize this - I don't think her first guess would be that it's really Jeyne Poole. Arya is smart so in this scenario she would probably rightly guess that it might be Jeyne because she fits a lot of the criteria that makes passing her off as Arya plausible and she was also in Kingslanding the same time Arya disappeared. But like Sansa who dismisses her own observations even though they're correct, Arya would likely dismiss it as impossible that it's Jeyne Poole as we don't have any indication that Arya thinks/knows/believes that Jeyne survived the attack, nor would she have anything showing her that she did.

Anonymous asked:

ooh saw the tourney post and what are your opinions on septa mordane? i know some people argue about it but i always thought she was unfair to both girls

I think she was an inadequate and unimaginative educator in Winterfell and an irresponsible guardian on the road and in King's Landing, who should have never been entrusted with the full responsibility of supervising the girls.

She used open shame to try and pressure Arya into making more of an effort, tried to do the same to Sansa, and she downright endangered the girls by both outsourcing her duty onto the more obedient child (making her fetch and instruct Arya) and by getting too drunk to escort Sansa home from an all-day high society event. Absolutely unacceptable failure that last one. How was she not instantly fired? Oh, because Ned never bothered to find out.

I also think that her job was made unecessarily harder in KL by the lack of support by Ned (who brushed off all misbehavior by Arya) and the lack of assistance in supervising two children with conflicting interests and schedules. Not that this excuses her.

I don't hate her, but I also prefer that the show tried to give her some nuance and made her more sympathetic. Book!Mordane is a lazy stereotype. Show!Mordane was a respectable equivalent to Syrio Forel, sacrificing herself to try and help Sansa escape. An infinitely superior choice, I think.

Avatar
Avatar

One of the most harrowing parts to me was that even in that goddamn dream where everything was supposed to be right, Shauna could not initially envision herself as a "good mother." She wasn't able to feed the baby, couldn't soothe his cries. And she wakes up after a nightmare where she couldn't save him—couldn't protect him from being ravaged by her monstrous friends—but there's no relief even in her waking hours. There's only the cold reality of his immediate death.

Why can't you hear him cry?

And then, less than ten years later—after all that horror, grief, and endless blood—she has another child, Callie, one that she doesn't even want, but she has her anyway to try and save her broken marriage. (And can you imagine how terrified she was to go through it all again? Nine months of waiting and waiting, when the last time she nearly died? And the baby died. And it all hurt so much, but maybe all of that pain was restitution for her bottomless guilt? Maybe it was punishment? Her just reward?)

And dammit and despite it all, she loves that baby—that is absolutely not what Shauna is lying to the cop about—but she holds Callie at arm's length anyway because even from the very beginning, she has told herself that she is a bad mother.

And she is.

That's indisputable.

She admits as much too.

But she loves her all the same.

How beautiful and terrible and so fucking tragic.

honestly i find the fandoms response to this idea of aemma arryn disliking alicent hightower amusing for several reasons. firstly because something that is often used to discredit alicent in f&b and paint her as the wicked stepmother figure is the fact that by the time rhaenyra was 13 there was clear and obvious dislike between them. but... there was a legitimate conflict and alicent had valid reasons to be concerned about the threats her sons' very existence would pose to rhaenyra's rule, not when maegor targaryen killed two of his nephews for the throne.

but hotd aemma? if she did dislike 14yo alicent... then i honestly think that would be pathetic because.... alicent hasn't done anything to earn it. there's no reason for this supposed conflict. she also could have done something by arranging for highborn girls to come to court so rhaenyra could have other companions besides alicent. but the fact she didn't idk leads me to believe that aemma hating her daughter's friend is in y'all heads and what's more the reaction to this idea is hypocritical as hell

i know its a fairly popular take that "aemma would hate alicent for calling her grandsons savages" and it seems to stem/be partly influenced from this idea that like viserys, aemma would turn a blind eye to their obvious bastardry. but like, if you actually think about it - the reality is that as soon as it became apparent to her who jace and luke's biological father was, aemma would have stepped in meaning it's unlikely joffrey would have even been born in the first place.

not only like the majority of westeros aemma would have been the practioner of the faith, but she grew up in the vale which i think after the reach/highgarden is the most pious. she would have been raised/conditioned to believe in certain expectations for noble women like her and her daughter. in fact the first and only conversation we see her have with rhaenyra on screen centres around this idea of duty. i'm not saying she wouldn't have felt sympathetic to the pressure rhaenyra was under, but i honestly think some of y'all deluding yourselves if you think she would have tolerated rhaenyra's actions like viserys because it suited him. as i said the reality is as soon as aemma realized the truth, she like most people would have wanted harwin removed from his position and kicked out of the red keep. which brings to my next point. being the kind of place that westeros is, most parents would have seen harwin's affair with their daughter as dishonouring her.

like ultimately i don't really care what aemma arryn would have thought about alicent and or her fighting for her children's claim over her rhaenyra's. i don't really care if she disliked a teenage alicent, even though she would have only known a girl that rhaenyra was close with. if she's the type that would have blamed alicent for going to viserys even though she clearly didn't want to and even then was only kind to him, similar to how viserys has the audacity to blame alicent when he finally clocked that she actually wasn't in love with him, then i guess she's just a bad person like her husband was.

but it's the way y'all treat aemma arryn by automatically assuming she would have supported what rhaenyra and harwin did, and never considering that she idk might have had thoughts and opinions that don't always align with her husband and daughter. what's more, in her limited screen time we actually see her disagreeing with rhaenyra and viserys. she doesn't like rhaenyra flying while she herself is pregnant. she doesn't take viserys' "dream" seriously nor is she confident like him that she will give birth to a son.