Disney & LGBTQ+
I am a Disney shill, i'll admit it. Their musicals and animated features are all wonderful, and their acquired properties like Marvel and Star Wars are borderline obsessions of mine. But I have one major problem (other than their money grabbing).
I'm Bisexual. I grew up in LDS Utah, in the very heart of it. I have been driven to be suicidal multiple times in my teenage years for how awful the culture is here against gay people. I oftentimes escape into what Disney creates, but i'm beginning to feel really hurt by them.
They refuse to give the LGBTQ+ community any sort of decent representation. They will champion that their new film is "A milestone for representation" then make it a scene they can easily cut out. In the live-action Beauty and the Beast their "groundbreaking" representation was a two second scene of Lafou dancing with a man. Valkyrie from the MCU is supposedly Bisexual but Watiti was never allowed to do anything with that. Then in Endgame it was an inconsequential scene of an unnamed character. Then in Rise of Skywalker it was two background characters who kissed. Then they pushed their new Love, Simon show from Disney+ to Hulu. The best we have gotten from them is in Onward with the lesbian cop, but again a background character with nothing but a passing mention of it. Nothing of substance.
Not to be rude and downplay what these characters mean to people, because something is better than nothing, but it feels pandering to me. Finnpoe was supposed to be canon and it didn't happen because of Disney. They keep claiming they support this community, but they make only passing mentions of background characters that can easily be removed for foreign markets. By doing this Disney tells me they only care about money, not what their representation actually means, and so it feels hollow at best.
What's frustrating is they make and support really good stories about LGBTQ+ feelings! Elsa is a great example of being forced to be closeted for something she was born with. She is ashamed and withdrawn and has tons of self loathing, and throughout both Frozen movies she grows to accept herself.
Likewise, The Clone Wars does this very well too. Granted, Disney did not make a vast majority of this show, but they continue to market it and allowed Season 7 to be what they wanted, so it still means something. The way the Jedi Order represses love and relationships strikes such a cord with me. What it does to Anakin is so realistically damaging and reflects how I was raised. Kenobi getting over Satine and living celibate in that show reminds me of all the gay people who are "strong in the church" and are denied their natural feelings. These people are shown to me, saying "you can make God happy too by denying your feelings!" And it clearly shows that Kenobi's experience also negatively affects Anakin, if not subtly.
So the point is is that Disney has the writing chops to craft AMAZING LGBTQ+ stories, but they refuse to. To explain let me tell you a story. The new short on Disney+ called Out is about a gay man coming out to his parents. It's short, harmless, and is only a drop in the bucket of their huge catalog on that platform. But my best friend's religious family hated it anyway, would not shut up about how awful it is, how they are sick of having gay people shoved down their throats, how they can't hate gay people without being hated on, and her family even discussed it with her grandparents.
Disney catters to these people. These awful, bigoted, hateful people. They cater to them for money. They don't make actual representation because all they care about is the bottom line. And I know they are a company, but they have so much money they can afford to make less of a profit on a few movies to really give LGBTQ+ something special, because they have proved they can make and support stories that strike a cord like that. But they won't. They don't actually care about my experiences, or my pain, or the escape they offer me. They only care about my wallet.
I know the upcoming MCU films The Eternals and Thor: Love and Thunder are supposed to have more representation, but with their track record I am not holding my breath.