not only do i remember this, I SAW IT ONSTAGE IN LONDON IN 2008
i was 18 years old on a school trip (which was somewhat motivated by the fact that you can drink in england when you’re 18 and you cannot in the us). we were asked ahead of time which shows we wanted to see. we were given a list. absolutely no one chose LOTR the musical. (or if they did, they never owned up to it).
every tour guide we encountered on this trip asked us if we were going to see any shows. we were going to see phantom, which was as you expected, a decent production, the chandelier falls, the phantom sings, there are no real surprises there. but when we told these poor tour guides that we were also seeing LOTR the musical, they got kind of quiet.
“i’ve heard the sets are really nice”
“they have some interesting sets”
“oh, i’ve heard good things about the set”
my friends, when you have spent a lot of money producing a west end musical, it should worry you when the nicest compliment anyone can give said musical is about the SET.
(the set was genuinely very cool, there were vines all throughout the audience, and the centerpiece of the set was a rotating circle with multiple levels that went up and down, it was nifty)
the puppets were also really dope
none of the comments so far have really captured the experience of seeing this show. the music was... fine. if you remember the late aughts you probably won’t be too surprised, instead of emo music it was off-brand enya for the most part. like if celtic women was sung by men from london. it’s all on youtube.
there are several things you need to know about the stage production:
1. i have no idea how the show opens. there were hobbits onstage as people were getting seated, and they had these massive nets they were waving over the heads of the audience, trying to catch fireflies. no idea how the fireflies worked, that was very cool but this was a liability lawsuit waiting to happen. anyway they caught the fireflies, shouted HUZZAH and the show began. nobody was prepared, there was no warning about fire exits, and everyone in the audience was still talking, so i missed the first 5 minutes
2. gandalf was yelling every single line, no explanation
3. aragorn had stripes of dark paint underneath his eyes like a football player, no explanation
4. arawen kept showing up in the background of scenes she was not in, such as the death of boromir, no explanation.
5b. i won’t dwell on it too much because it is on youtube, but the lothlorien song is exactly as describe above, EXCEPT in addition to the ribbon dancing there were AERIALS. legolas comes swinging in on a vine, galadriel has a vine/sex swing setup, it was Camp.
6. the orcs. had pogo sticks. for hands.
6b. i need to emphasize this: the orcs HAD POCO STICKS FOR HANDS!!
they used these appendages like sproingy crutches and also as weapons during the fight scenes. why.
7. act 1 ends with the balrog showing up and there’s a rain of gold confetti glitter and a bunch of orcs are in the audience snarling at everyone and oh by the way they’re doing all 3 books.
8. during intermission everyone who wasn’t with a school trip from the u.s. got drunk, no explanation necessary
9b. gollum is wearing a skin-tight costume with a skimpy little tarzan loincloth, and he is giving a very crotch-forward performance. i’m talking crab-walking on his back with his pelvis thrusting with every line. gollum is giving us the most blatant display of raw sexuality i have ever seen in my life. gollum does not just want the precious. gollum is HORNY for the precious.
this actor deserves every award for doing the absolute worst thing in the best way possible.
10 (??). there is another part of the show i did not see, despite being in the audience, and it’s a song that is not part of the album, i think it was maybe supposed to be aragorn’s wedding? anyway, a bunch of extras walk out onstage in what might be gondor soldier uniforms, but they are some very white robes with some very pointy hoods, and perhaps presciently, they are carrying what appear to be tiki torches. someone in the (very drunk) audience shouts KKK, the actors pause, and then they just walk offstage, never to be seen again.
11. the ring gets thrown into the lava, galadriel shows up on her sex swing again, gandalf is alive and screaming about his friend tom bombadil, who does not make an appearance, the show is over and we leave, knowing innately that we will never be the same again
12. the dude who shouted kkk is outside getting arrested, which is an absolutely bananas reason to have an arrest record, wonder what his life is like now, maybe it was boris johnson, it probably wasn’t, but don’t know, who can say.
anyway, dream a little dream of gollum, whose knee pads require no explanation: