Do compulsive/pathological liars have different brain structure?
The answer is yes. Numerous studies have converged in designating prefrontal white matter as the likely culprit behind all the lies. This increase in prefrontal white matter is also found in individuals that lie, cheat and manipulate others. Sounds bad…
Back in 2005, Yang et. al found an abnormal prefrontal white matter increase in the brains of pathological liars. The group postulated that perhaps this increase resulted in a predisposition towards lying. In 2007, the group examined white matter differences in four prefrontal areas by using structural magnetic resonance imaging (MRI).
Prefrontal areas exhibiting increased white matter (in the liars’ brains) were:
- Orbitofrontal cortex (22-26% increase)
- Inferior frontal cortex (32-36% increase)
- Middle frontal cortex (28-32% increase)
So how does one explain these differences?
There are many options. Among the ones I find most interesting are:
- This pre-existing variation of prefrontal structures may render individuals susceptible to pathological lying.
- Excessive and repetitive lying activates the prefrontal circuitry underlying pathological lying.
Another thing that I find very fascinating is that these prefrontal regions also happen to be implicated in executive functions essential for deception like decision-making and moral reasoning!
Other studies from nonhuman primates have suggested a role for larger neocortices in the act of deception.
on Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder
I’m not going to argue whether or not this is a real disorder - the science and my own personal experiences lead me to very much know it’s a Real Thing and not just some thing made up by doctors to push amphetamines onto children. Not that that doesn’t happen, but it’s not a negation of the condition itself. Rather, what I intend to do is give you a little insight into what exactly it is like for someone with ADHD, how they perceive the world, and what phenomenological reality is like for them. I say this as someone who has been diagnosed with ADHD. I have been diagnosed only after submitting to numerous mental and physical health evaluations.
I also don’t claim to speak for anyone but myself. It’s very well possible someone else with ADHD might feel differently or experience different things, and that’s fine. However, something leads me to believe that what I’m going to write will resonate with a lot of individuals. Regardless of that, this is just me personally - it’s not indicative of how everyone else experiences it.
There are numerous aspects to ADHD that most neurotypical people cannot relate to. Obviously, our attention span is severely decreased. It’s hard for us to focus. We have trouble staying on task. Etc etc - you know the basic story. But, digging deeper than that, what is the experience of life like for person with ADHD? What of our percetions, our interpretations, our way we view the world? How does that differ?
I never really noticed this until I was critiqued during a public speaking seminar, but in person I am an extremely fast talker. I sound like I”m rambling about a million words per minute. Ask anyone on this site who has met me in person, and I’m sure they will agree (unless I’m stoned/drunk/nodding-off) with that. I asked Kate about it, and that’s what she told me.
That got me thinking: why do I talk fast? From my own point of view, whn I am talking to someone in person, I don’t feel like I’m talking fast. In fact, I think the opposite: I think that the other person is slow. Even though they might be normal compared to everyone else, for me normal = slow.
That got me thinking even more. And when I sat down and finally thought things out, I came to a conclusion:individuals who have ADHD perceive each individual unit of time on a smaller scale than a neurotypical/non-ADHD person does.
To explain, consider the following. Let us take a neurotypical person, call them X. The minimum threshold under which X can notice any sort of change is 1 second. In other words,it takes X one second - on average - to notice a change in their environment. Now consider a person Y. For Y, this time is 1/2 of a second. Y, who is diagnosed with ADHD, can perceive changes in their environment within 1/2 of a second after they occur. The ratio doesn’t matter so much as it is the fact that an individual with ADHD is more “sensitive to time” than a neurotypical individual.
I think this explains a lot about ADHD. We get disatracted easily. Why is that? Well, we perceive more than you do. Not necessarily more, but rather because we perceive a more fine level of detail in change of time, our attention naturally matches our enhanced time-sensitivity. And that enhanced sensitivity to time causes us to notice more things, and thus get distracted.
There’s a lot more to ADHD than just time-sensitivity. A LOT more, for sure. But I haven’t seen this sort of detail written about in the literature. Coming from someone who has been diagnosed with ADHD for over 10 years, this is one way in which I feel ADHD affects the brain.
It’s not necessarily a negative thing. It absolutely can have repercussions, but there are also benefits. I’m not saying it’s a bad thing - it’s simply not the norm.
Chimpanzee's born with immature frontal lobes, Like Humans.
On August 11, 2011, Current Biology are the firs to track the development of the chimpanzee brain to the human brain in comparison.
Tetsuro Matsuzawa of Kyoto University in Japan says “One of the most marked evolutionary changes underlying human-specific cognitive traits is a greatly enlarged prefrontal cortex. It is also one of the latest-developing brain regions of the cerebrum.”
He also says, “Both humans and chimpanzees need to render their neural network and brain function more suspectible to the influence of postnatal experience.”
Chimps and humans both enjoy close relationships between their young and adults, like smiles and mutual gazes. But, the greater prefrontal expansion in the human brain may give a role in development of language, complex social infrastructure, and other abilities that make us unique.
Matsuzawa’s team made the discovery of this by magnetic reasonance imaging (MRI) studies of 3 growing chimpanzees from the age of 6 months to 6 years. Chimpanezee’s reach pre-puberty at the age of 6 years old.
In the last ancestor of chimpanzees and humans, the studies suggest that they were less mature and more protracted on their neural connection in the prefrontal portions of the brain. The last ancestor to human and chimps were called, macaques.
Matsuzawa says that his group was interested in exploring the development of the brain over evolution. The team was hoping to compare the humans and chimps brains into the young adulthood. They noted that chimps also enter late puberty at the age of 11-years old.