Follow posts tagged #manmohan singh, #li keqiang, and #india in seconds.

Sign up

The Death of Manmohanomics

readability.com

On 14 November, top Finance Ministry officials made a crucial PowerPoint presentation to the global credit rating agency, Moody’s. Scared that the latter may downgrade India’s sovereign rating, as it had done with the country’s banking sector the previous week, the bureaucrats listed out a dozen big-ticket reforms that UPA-II had initiated in the recent past. It was an aggressive attempt to conclusively prove that there was no policy paralysis within the Government.

Ironically, and shockingly, the items that the bureaucrats discussed confirmed quite the opposite. The exercise established that Manmohan Singh and his A-team were unable to push through critical but politically sensitive decisions. It indicated that in the current political atmosphere—characterised by corruption scandals, squabbles among Cabinet ministers, bureaucratic coma, and fear and loathing within India Inc—governance and policymaking had lost almost all traction.

India’s ‘silent’ prime minister becomes a tragic figure

washingtonpost.com

image

NEW DELHI — India’s Prime Minister Manmohan Singh helped set his country on the path to modernity, prosperity and power, but critics say the shy, soft-spoken 79-year-old is in danger of going down in history as a failure.

The architect of India’s economic reforms, Singh was a major force behind his country’s rapprochement with the United States and is a respected figure on the world stage. President Obama’s aides used to boast of his tremendous rapport and friendship with Singh.

But the image of the scrupulously honorable, humble and intellectual technocrat has slowly given way to a completely different one: a dithering, ineffectual bureaucrat presiding over a deeply corrupt government.

Every day for the past two weeks, India’s Parliament has been adjourned as the opposition bays for Singh’s resignation over allegations of waste and corruption in the allocation of coal-mining concessions.

The story of Singh’s dramatic fall from grace in his second term in office and the slow but steady tarnishing of his reputation has played out in parallel with his country’s decline on his watch. As India’s economy has slowed and as its reputation for rampant corruption has reasserted itself, the idea that the country was on an inexorable road to becoming a global power has increasingly come into question.

“More and more, he has become a tragic figure in our history,” said political historian Ramachandra Guha, describing a man fatally handicapped by his “timidity, complacency and intellectual dishonesty.”

The irony is that Singh’s greatest selling points — his incorruptibility and economic experience — are the mirror image of his government’s greatest failings.

Under Singh, economic reforms have stalled, growth has slowed sharply and the rupee has collapsed. But just as damaging to his reputation is the accusation that he looked the other way and remained silent as his cabinet colleagues filled their own pockets.

In the process, he transformed himself from an object of respect to one of ridicule and endured the worst period in his life, said Sanjaya Baru, Singh’s media adviser during his first term.

Attendees at meetings and conferences were jokingly urged to put their phones into “Manmohan Singh mode,” while one joke cited a dentist urging the seated prime minister, “At least in my clinic, please open your mouth.”

Singh finally did open his mouth last week, to rebut criticism from the government auditor that the national treasury had been cheated of billions of dollars after coal-mining concessions were granted to private companies for a pittance — including during a five-year period when Singh doubled as coal minister.

Singh denied that there was “any impropriety,” but he was drowned out by catcalls when he attempted to address Parliament on the issue. His brief statement to the media afterward appeared to do little to change the impression of a man whose aloofness from the rough-and-tumble of Indian politics has been transformed from an asset into a liability.

“It has been my general practice not to respond to motivated criticism directed personally at me,” he said. “My general attitude has been, ‘My silence is better than a thousand answers; it keeps intact the honor of innumerable questions.’ ”

it’s not a bric summit without an awkward handshake

image

image

image

success

Falling Man

caravanmagazine.in

In a 1996 interview, Singh had been asked point-blank about his aspirations for the top job, and his response was uncharacteristically blunt: “Who doesn’t want to be prime minister?”

In fact, Singh was secretly approached two years later, in 1998, with a proposition to put him forward as a prime ministerial candidate. The Congress was fractured at that point in time, and the era of unstable coalitions had begun. A senior Congress leader who had joined Mamata Banerjee’s breakaway Trinamool Congress told me that he and Banerjee had hatched a plan early in 1998 to approach Singh—who was then unhappy in the Congress—and offer him a safe seat in North West Calcutta. They were confident that the upcoming snap elections would deliver a repeat of 1996, with no party as a decisive winner, and believed they could cobble together a coalition with Manmohan Singh as the prime minister.

“I went to his Safdarjung Road residence and put this proposition to him, to join the Trinamool Congress,” the senior leader told me. “I said, I’m authorised by Mamata Banerjee to offer you a ticket from North West Calcutta, the constituency of the aristocratic Bengalis—the Bhadralok. There is no way anyone could beat you there, and after the elections the prime ministership will be offered to you on a platter.”

“Do you know what Manmohan Singh said?” the leader continued. “He said, ‘This country will not accept a Sikh as the Prime Minister.’”

Every Third Malnourished Child is an Indian

moneycontrol.com

The statistics in the HUNGaMA (Hunger and Malnutrition) report say that every third malnourished child on the planet is an Indian.

Prime Minister Manmohan Singh released the first-ever citizens’ report on child malnutrition in the national capital on Tuesday, January 10, 2012.

The Prime Minister stated that “The problem of malnutrition is a national shame,” and “despite impressive growth in our GDP, the level of malnutrition is unacceptably high.”

I’ve finally figured out what to write my term paper on, and being the only Indian in the class it’s going to be interesting to see the responses from my peers. I wouldn’t be surprised if half of them don’t even know where India is or that the issue of undernourishment and orphaned children is even taking place around the world. The articles surrounding this topic are extremely depressing. We’ve got it good here, there have to be more ways to help these kids in India.

Wikileaks: 'Reached understanding with Musharraf on Kashmir,' India PM told US delegation

ndtv.com

A US diplomatic cable leaked by whistleblower website WikiLeaks quotes Prime Minister Manmohan Singh as saying that in 2006, he had reached an “understanding” on Kashmir with then Pakistan President Pervez Musharraf.

The cable claims Dr Manmohan Singh told an American delegation in April 2008 that “We had reached an understanding in back-channels, in which Musharraf had agreed to a non-territorial solution to Kashmir that included freedom of movement and trade.”

“‘Questioned by Representative Sheila Jackson-Lee about relations with Pakistan, the Prime Minister said Delhi and Islamabad had made great progress prior to February 2007, when President Musharraf ran into trouble,” the cable adds.

It also quotes the PM as saying that “India wants a strong, stable, peaceful, democratic Pakistan and makes no claim on ‘even an inch’ of Pakistani territory.”

Pakistan’s former Foreign Minister Khurshid Mahmud Kasuri had told NDTV in January this year that both India and Pakistan had almost signed off on a draft agreement on Kashmir. This agreement included self-governance on both sides of the Line of Control and a joint mechanism to oversee governance, he had said. (Read)

Mr Kasuri had also claimed that India and Pakistan’s near resolution of the Kashmir issue had the backing of Pakistan’s present Army Chief General Ashfaq Kayani.

NDTV

Falling Man

caravanmagazine.in

In a 1996 interview, Singh had been asked point-blank about his aspirations for the top job, and his response was uncharacteristically blunt: “Who doesn’t want to be prime minister?”

In fact, Singh was secretly approached two years later, in 1998, with a proposition to put him forward as a prime ministerial candidate. The Congress was fractured at that point in time, and the era of unstable coalitions had begun. A senior Congress leader who had joined Mamata Banerjee’s breakaway Trinamool Congress told me that he and Banerjee had hatched a plan early in 1998 to approach Singh—who was then unhappy in the Congress—and offer him a safe seat in North West Calcutta. They were confident that the upcoming snap elections would deliver a repeat of 1996, with no party as a decisive winner, and believed they could cobble together a coalition with Manmohan Singh as the prime minister.

“I went to his Safdarjung Road residence and put this proposition to him, to join the Trinamool Congress,” the senior leader told me. “I said, I’m authorised by Mamata Banerjee to offer you a ticket from North West Calcutta, the constituency of the aristocratic Bengalis—the Bhadralok. There is no way anyone could beat you there, and after the elections the prime ministership will be offered to you on a platter.”

“Do you know what Manmohan Singh said?” the leader continued. “He said, ‘This country will not accept a Sikh as the Prime Minister.’”

okay, let's also not get crazy

As inspirational as this anti-graft, anti-corruption movement has been, let’s not call the Prime Minister, Manmohan Singh, a corrupt leader.

He may have exhibited cognitive dissonance as regards the public mood, been adrift from the common man’s problems and even exhibited timidity in tackling issues of a draconian scale, like corruption.

But let’s not accuse the one honest man in politics, who has been incorruptible through 40 years of public service, of being corrupt. It’s times like this where enormous consequences hang in the balance that we need to be discerning and thoughtful as a people.

It’s possible to do this while being uncompromising of the spirit and goals of the movement. Let’s not lose our ability to see through things and see things through. 


Loading more posts...