hs!au where Cas is the quiet, uptight sophmore who’s president of the Bible Club, always wears sweater vests, and takes everything in with wide, blue eyes, curious as a cat’s.

One night his sister Anna tells him she’s taking him for ice cream, but instead she takes him to a party where he ends up eating loaded brownies and getting baked enough to finally tell Dean Winchester, the cute, senior, soccer player with the freckles, just how cute Cas thinks Dean’s butt is. They end up making out in a closet.

At the end of the night Dean takes Cas home (Anna was last seen leaving with her crush Ruby) and walking him to his doorstep, leaving Cas with a kiss on the forehead and Dean’s phone number tucked safely in the pocket of Cas’ jacket.