Ok so, I watched the last episode of Pretty Little Liars, and I felt like something did not fit. In this Christmas episode we can see a letter Bethany sent to Alison, implying strongly that Ali was the one to attract her to Rosewood the night she got murdered and that she is the one who told her to put the yellow top she wore.
Is it labour day yet? I can’t tell you how grateful I am to have something to look forward to. I’ve been biding my time with art I found a sketchbook in the art box last week, and I’m just a few pages shy of filling it.
I’m counting the days until I can get out of here. Did you tell your friends I am coming? I can’t wait to meet them I just want to feel like a normal person again.
Did I already thank you for the clothes in my last letter? If not, thank you times a million yellow is my favourite color.
Can’t wait to see you xo – Bethany” (great thanks to tumblr user wunderlan-d for the pic and the text)
But I can’t shake off the face of Alison when she discovered in episode 5 that the dead body in her grave was the one of Bethany. And unless she is –A or hiding a huge secret (like murder level) there is no reason she would never mention her to the girls, especially when she wanted them to help her find out who –A is at the very end of season 4. But most of all, it is clear that Bethany hated Alison in the records and files Mona and the girls discovered.
So my theory is that –A wrote and put this letter in this box. And to go further I believe that Mona never left any notes to Hanna, but that –A wrote those themselves. The plan to Ali’s house? Where to look at to find clues? Big –A material. Also what kind of lawyer just drop some envelope on a Christmas night, without checking any ID or making sign any paper anyway?
I also believe that –A went to Alison’s house to check if the girls fell in this trap. Why not harm Spencer or Hanna? Why the knife then? Why staying? I think they just came to be sure that they discovered the letter that incriminate Alison.
And to conclude, this letter is a literal “get out of jail card” for Spencer, which she mention before –A gave them the “glass snowball”, and is the best gift someone could have get her. After all –A wished them “Merry Christmas” at the end of the episode, something you say when you give a gift to someone.
Also do not forget:
Tell me what you think about it!