Oh! I have been selected to represent NY for an important National Referendum. Just let me open this official looking envelope…
How cute. PETA sent me a survey about cruelty to cats and dogs. Lets see what it says.
Was I aware of the trade in cat and dog fur before reading this letter? Yes I was. In that it is highly illegal (NYS Agriculture and Markets Law, Article 26 Section 379) People do illegal things. Most of the illegal domestic fur trade comes in the form of imports from foreign countries such as China. As with all fur, look at sources before you buy.
Did I know animals who are killed for their fur are often domestic animals stolen from their families? Overseas I will admit to not being fully informed as to crime patterns. US, I know that dogs are stolen and resold rather regularly. And that people give away pets on Craigslist fairly regularly. Seller beware and don’t leave pets unattended. Again, the bulk of the illegal cat and dog fur trade is from overseas.
Was I aware cat and dog fur is being sold under different labeling in the US and Europe? Not specifically cat and dog, but again, look before you buy and be informed. Simple as that. If it is a cheap and sketchy source, it is probably sketchy fur.
Were you aware that fur traders use methods such as drowning animals and bludgeoning them and skinning them alive to save money and avoid damaging the fur? Ok. Here is where you and I really have words, PETA. How the hell does bludgeoning or skinning alive NOT damage the fur? And how is drowning easier than dispatching at the trap site with a single shot? Here you are really just trying to get people riled up and I am calling bullshit. Loudly. Skinning is a pain in the ass when the trapper is not causing the animal constant pain, pain causing involuntary motion. Cruelty aside, it is not in a trappers interest to skin alive as it will damage the fur and therefore their livelihood. Seriously. Get that into your heads. Same as bludgeoning. A bullet or knife is easier and leaves marks on the pelt that are easily repaired. For the love of all that is holy can we get beyond the improbable skinning alive argument. It is raising my ire, but not in the direction you want. Trust me. Side note on bludgeoning- all parts of the animal can be made use of, including skeletal remains.
Did you know cats and dogs can continue to breathe and blink for up to five minutes after being skinned alive? I am sorry you skinned something alive to get this data. The trappers are not. See above for information on irrationality of the skinning alive thought process.
Did you know kittens and puppies are often killed for their fur? I will admit it is soft. But again, most of the illegal fur trade is from outside the country. So…I fear you are again using things that are tailor made to get people fussy, in this case puppies and kittens, to win them to your cause.
Do you think it is ever morally justifiable to kill animals so that their fur can be used for clothing, furnishing, and trinkets? You mailed to the wrong house. Yes. I believe in the use of the whole animal. I eat meat, I utilize leather, I wear jewelry made of bone and I have ritual wear respectfully made of pelts. Trappers have been doing their jobs since we sorted out how to catch and kill our food. It is highly regulated and the money that comes in from all of those hunting and trapping permits goes right back into conservation. If we did not hunt and trap there were be issues of overpopulation, disease, and a lot more ‘pest’ animals in your back yard. We are living where the animals used to. There has to be a balance to that struck.
Go away, PETA. You bother me. And shame on you for using cats and dogs to rile people up about fur in general- your last question being whether or not I would be willing to send you money to save the lives of animals, such as cats and dogs, who are killed for their fur. I am a writer. I see what you did there.
If you are worried about the sources of your meat, your leather, your fur, it takes an internet search to find out where it came from. Research and learn. Find people you can respect and trust and work with them. If you don’t do the animal product gig, that is fantastic. Rock on, just respect that it is not my gig. And that entities like PETA who spout nonsense and are not straightforward in their intent and spread misinformation will consistently raise my hackles. It is not you, it is not a vegan/vegetarian lifestyle. It is the misinformation that pisses me the hell off.