On Charles having disfigurement/burns on their face: Do you think that he could have been in the shed when the Jenna thing happened? and that's maybe why they're seeking revenge on the girls? idk something about the Jenna thing doesn't add up to me.
Your right… there are heaps of things that don’t add up with the Jenna thing:
- Alison apparently did that to Toby because he spied on them - which he actually didn’t do and he even said that Alison did it cause she thought she had something on him but she was wrong.
- She only threw a stink bomb, but the garage exploded - much like Toby’s whole house did season’s later from a supposed “gas leak” cough coug bullsh*t
- Jenna said herself that she could see right from the first operation (which was actually back whilst Alison was still alive) So her blindness or lack of doesn’t match up.
- Toby must have been involved with something back then because his mother’s death is a big part of the show and is very suspicious.
Personally I would love it if Charles was burned in the fire and that is the reason he is seeking revenge. But I would love it even more if Black Veil (aka the real and only original A) was the one who tricked Alison into throwing the stick bomb!!!